The Valley Chronicle - AMR sets record straight on Ai Spang
AMR sets record straight on Ai Spa
New information on response timeline raises even more questions
[caption id="attachment_5927" align="alignright" width="576"] File PhotoAi Spa, which closed in February 2016, still has signage out and the space has not been made available for rent to other businesses.[/caption] ■ Melissa Diaz Hernandez / Editor The Valley Chronicle has repeatedly reported on the circumstances of a February 2016 death at a local massage parlor that was suspected of human trafficking. A retired employee of the Metropolitan Water District (MWD) died on scene in a massage parlor that advertised on backpage.com, a known sex-trafficking website. The Valley Chronicle has requested public documents from many agencies, including the Hemet Police Department (HPD), MWD, Eastern Municipal Water District (EMWD), Riverside County Coroner’s office, Hemet Fire Department (HFD) and American Medical Response (AMR). While HPD refused to provide anything except the deceased man’s name and age, HFD ultimately responded with an incident report, and the Coroner’s office provided a redacted report. The newspaper requested records from MWD and EMWD several times before we received a response regarding the deceased’s former employment. When the Chronicle requested the incident report via phone call to AMR, we were told that AMR was a private company and therefore not subject to the California Public Records Act (CPRA), so no additional information would be provided. However, when we ran the updated story, we included a telltale piece of information that got AMR’s attention. The Hemet Fire Department incident report stated that AMR’s response time to the Ai Spa was 33 minutes. “Not true,” said the company, and it wanted to correct the record. According to the company, on Feb. 4, 2016, AMR was contacted by dispatch at 2:10:27 p.m. The first keystroke was recorded by AMR at 2:10:41 p.m. and an AMR unit was assigned at 2:11:03 p.m., less than one minute after AMR answered the call. The initial unit assigned to the Ai Spa at 301 E. Florida Ave. was rerouted approximately one and a half minutes into the call at 2:12:31 p.m. because another ambulance was able to arrive sooner, according to an AMR representative. The ambulance arrived on scene at 2:19:25 p.m., giving AMR a response time of just under nine minutes, not the 33 minutes and four seconds recorded by HFD. According to HFD report, AMR arrived at 2:43:24 p.m. We asked Hemet Fire Chief Scott Brown about the discrepancy between the two recorded response times. “It was an error on how it was recorded,” said Brown. “HFD and AMR were on-scene -- HFD pronounced the patient following established protocol; I did speak to the captain who confirmed the same,” he said. “It would not have altered the outcome.” AMR told The Valley Chronicle that its ambulance was on the scene for 55 minutes and the total call time was 1 hour 3 minutes and 35 seconds. Its incident report backs up their claim. However, the fire incident report recorded AMR’s release from the scene less than a minute after the fire department’s reported AMR arrival time at 2:43:44 p.m. Communications between AMR dispatch and the responding unit, recorded in the incident detail report, stated that at 3:03:57 p.m. AMR was “safe on-scene.” The communication was in response to a “safety check” message sent at 2:52:57 p.m. Due to the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA), The Valley Chronicle is unable to obtain any documentation from Riverside County EMS Agency (REMSA) other than what was provided by AMR. Obtaining any further information from REMSA would require a subpoena, unless a family member retrieved it and then provided the documentation. After multiple attempts by the Chronicle to obtain the police report from the Hemet Police Department -- which have all been rebuffed--the newspaper is at a loss as to why the information is still being withheld more than a year and a half later. Learning that there were discrepancies in the reporting just raises further questions. What happened that day? The citizens of Hemet -- and the victim’s family -- deserve to know.
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Dec 15, 2022
Soboba Band of Luiseño Indians
staffLeprechauns bring lots of green to Soboba Tribal Preschool
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Feb 25, 2021
Koi Nation of Northern California and California State Parks
staffKoi Nation of Northern California, USA
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Dec 8, 2022
24 Kids Shop with a Cop in Hemet
staff24 Kids Shop with a Cop in Hemet
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Dec 8, 2022
MSJC Hosts Temecula Valley Campus Dedication Ceremony
staffMSJC Hosts Temecula Valley Campus Dedication Ceremony
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Dec 8, 2022
NFPA urges added caution this holiday season, as Christ
staffNFPA urges added caution this holiday season, as Christmas Day and Christmas Eve are among the leading days of the year for U.S. home fires
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Dec 8, 2022
Stick to a “Go Safely” Game Plan: Celebrate the Holiday
staffStick to a “Go Safely” Game Plan: Celebrate the Holiday Season Responsibly National “Drive Sober or Get Pulled Over” Enforcement Campaign Begins Dec. 14
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Oct 27, 2022
Padilla Hosts Virtual Federal Student Debt Relief Brief
staffPadilla Hosts Virtual Federal Student Debt Relief Briefing to Encourage Californians to Apply
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Jun 9, 2022
Police Seek Help Locating Hit-and-Run Vehicle
staffPolice Seek Help Locating Hit-and-Run Vehicle
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Jun 9, 2022
Four CSUSB alumni win top award for radio show
staffFour CSUSB alumni win top award for radio show
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Jun 9, 2022
Follow-up: Plane Crashes Near Residential Homes in Heme
staffFollow-up: Plane Crashes Near Residential Homes in Hemet
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Jun 9, 2022
CSUSB Nursing Street Medicine Program partners with new
staffCSUSB Nursing Street Medicine Program partners with new mobile medical clinic
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Jun 9, 2022
Padilla Joins Farm Workers for a Workday as Part of the
staffPadilla Joins Farm Workers for a Workday as Part of the ‘Take Our Jobs’ Campaign
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Mar 24, 2022
CHP plans DUI checkpoint in Hemet Valley
staffCHP plans DUI checkpoint in Hemet Valley
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Mar 24, 2022
Don't undermine scientific discovery -- ever, but espec
staffDon't undermine scientific discovery -- ever, but especially now
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Mar 24, 2022
C.W. Driver companies breaks ground on new three-story
staffC.W. Driver companies breaks ground on new three-story stem education building
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Mar 24, 2022
35.3% Of Unvaccinated California Residents Cite Governm
staff35.3% Of Unvaccinated California Residents Cite Government Distrust
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Mar 24, 2022
ICYMI: Padilla Highlights From Judge Jackson’s Supreme
staffICYMI: Padilla Highlights From Judge Jackson’s Supreme Court Confirmation Hearing
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Mar 24, 2022
MSJC Celebrates Groundbreaking of New STEM Building and
staffMSJC Celebrates Groundbreaking of New STEM Building and Opening of New Animatronic Makerspace
English, Valley Chronicle: Thu, Mar 3, 2022
MSJC Receives $500,000 Apprenticeship Grant
staffMSJC Receives $500,000 Apprenticeship Grant
AMR sets record straight on Ai Spa
New information on response timeline raises even more questions
[caption id="attachment_5927" align="alignright" width="576"] File PhotoAi Spa, which closed in February 2016, still has signage out and the space has not been made available for rent to other businesses.[/caption] ■ Melissa Diaz Hernandez / Editor The Valley Chronicle has repeatedly reported on the circumstances of a February 2016 death at a local massage parlor that was suspected of human trafficking. A retired employee of the Metropolitan Water District (MWD) died on scene in a massage parlor that advertised on backpage.com, a known sex-trafficking website. The Valley Chronicle has requested public documents from many agencies, including the Hemet Police Department (HPD), MWD, Eastern Municipal Water District (EMWD), Riverside County Coroner’s office, Hemet Fire Department (HFD) and American Medical Response (AMR). While HPD refused to provide anything except the deceased man’s name and age, HFD ultimately responded with an incident report, and the Coroner’s office provided a redacted report. The newspaper requested records from MWD and EMWD several times before we received a response regarding the deceased’s former employment. When the Chronicle requested the incident report via phone call to AMR, we were told that AMR was a private company and therefore not subject to the California Public Records Act (CPRA), so no additional information would be provided. However, when we ran the updated story, we included a telltale piece of information that got AMR’s attention. The Hemet Fire Department incident report stated that AMR’s response time to the Ai Spa was 33 minutes. “Not true,” said the company, and it wanted to correct the record. According to the company, on Feb. 4, 2016, AMR was contacted by dispatch at 2:10:27 p.m. The first keystroke was recorded by AMR at 2:10:41 p.m. and an AMR unit was assigned at 2:11:03 p.m., less than one minute after AMR answered the call. The initial unit assigned to the Ai Spa at 301 E. Florida Ave. was rerouted approximately one and a half minutes into the call at 2:12:31 p.m. because another ambulance was able to arrive sooner, according to an AMR representative. The ambulance arrived on scene at 2:19:25 p.m., giving AMR a response time of just under nine minutes, not the 33 minutes and four seconds recorded by HFD. According to HFD report, AMR arrived at 2:43:24 p.m. We asked Hemet Fire Chief Scott Brown about the discrepancy between the two recorded response times. “It was an error on how it was recorded,” said Brown. “HFD and AMR were on-scene -- HFD pronounced the patient following established protocol; I did speak to the captain who confirmed the same,” he said. “It would not have altered the outcome.” AMR told The Valley Chronicle that its ambulance was on the scene for 55 minutes and the total call time was 1 hour 3 minutes and 35 seconds. Its incident report backs up their claim. However, the fire incident report recorded AMR’s release from the scene less than a minute after the fire department’s reported AMR arrival time at 2:43:44 p.m. Communications between AMR dispatch and the responding unit, recorded in the incident detail report, stated that at 3:03:57 p.m. AMR was “safe on-scene.” The communication was in response to a “safety check” message sent at 2:52:57 p.m. Due to the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA), The Valley Chronicle is unable to obtain any documentation from Riverside County EMS Agency (REMSA) other than what was provided by AMR. Obtaining any further information from REMSA would require a subpoena, unless a family member retrieved it and then provided the documentation. After multiple attempts by the Chronicle to obtain the police report from the Hemet Police Department -- which have all been rebuffed--the newspaper is at a loss as to why the information is still being withheld more than a year and a half later. Learning that there were discrepancies in the reporting just raises further questions. What happened that day? The citizens of Hemet -- and the victim’s family -- deserve to know.
The Valley Chronicle - AMR sets record straight on Ai Spang
AMR sets record straight on Ai Spa
Koi Nation of Northern California and California State Parks Renew Memorandum of Understanding and Celebrate Renaming of Ridge and Trail
Koi Nation of Northern California, USA
MSJC Hosts Temecula Valley Campus Dedication Ceremony
MSJC Hosts Temecula Valley Campus Dedication Ceremony
Stick to a “Go Safely” Game Plan: Celebrate the Holiday
Stick to a “Go Safely” Game Plan: Celebrate the Holiday Season Responsibly National “Drive Sober or Get Pulled Over” Enforcement Campaign Begins Dec. 14
Police Seek Help Locating Hit-and-Run Vehicle
Police Seek Help Locating Hit-and-Run Vehicle
Follow-up: Plane Crashes Near Residential Homes in Hemet
Follow-up: Plane Crashes Near Residential Homes in Hemet
Padilla Joins Farm Workers for a Workday as Part of the
Padilla Joins Farm Workers for a Workday as Part of the ‘Take Our Jobs’ Campaign
Don't undermine scientific discovery -- ever, but espec
Don't undermine scientific discovery -- ever, but especially now
35.3% Of Unvaccinated California Residents Cite Governm
35.3% Of Unvaccinated California Residents Cite Government Distrust
MSJC Celebrates Groundbreaking of New STEM Building and
MSJC Celebrates Groundbreaking of New STEM Building and Opening of New Animatronic Makerspace
MSJC Receives $500,000 Apprenticeship Grant
MSJC Receives $500,000 Apprenticeship Grant
24 Kids Shop with a Cop in Hemet
24 Kids Shop with a Cop in Hemet
Stick to a “Go Safely” Game Plan: Celebrate the Holiday
Stick to a “Go Safely” Game Plan: Celebrate the Holiday Season Responsibly National “Drive Sober or Get Pulled Over” Enforcement Campaign Begins Dec. 14
Four CSUSB alumni win top award for radio show
Four CSUSB alumni win top award for radio show
Padilla Joins Farm Workers for a Workday as Part of the
Padilla Joins Farm Workers for a Workday as Part of the ‘Take Our Jobs’ Campaign
C.W. Driver companies breaks ground on new three-story
C.W. Driver companies breaks ground on new three-story stem education building
MSJC Celebrates Groundbreaking of New STEM Building and
MSJC Celebrates Groundbreaking of New STEM Building and Opening of New Animatronic Makerspace